Open since February 2009.

At NYPD Pizza Lake Cay, we’re proud to bring you authentic New York–style pizza served with warm, family-friendly hospitality. Owners Jeff and Cheryl Longo, along with our dedicated management team—Katie, JP, and Colby—are committed to making every visit delicious and memorable. Whether you’re joining us for a casual lunch, family dinner, or game night with friends, we’re proud to be your neighborhood spot for great food, great service, and a slice of New York right here in Orlando. Come hungry—we’ll take care of the rest!