NYPD Pizza Winter Garden, FL

16118 Marsh Road
Winter Garden, FL 34787



Phone:
407-877-4743

Dine-in / Take-out / Delivery

Hours:
Mon: 4pm to 9pm
Tues & Thurs: 11am to 9pm
Friday: 11am to 10pm
Sat: 12pm to 10pm
Sun: 12pm to 9pm

The NYPD Pizza Winter Garden restaurant with a beige and red façade, front windows displaying graphics, and small trees along the walkway.

About NYPD Pizza Winter Garden, FL

Opened in August 2008 by Paul Overeem, NYPD Pizza in Winter Garden became a local favorite for authentic New York-style pizza and classic NYC dishes. In 2024, ownership passed to his daughters, Priscilla Sloan and Paula Aponte. Today, Priscilla Sloan and Gerardo Miguel lead the restaurant, continuing its tradition of serving great food with a nostalgic New York feel. For nearly two decades, this Winter Garden location has welcomed locals and visitors alike, bringing a taste of New York to the heart of Florida.